The 1880 Milan congress did not ban American Sign Language by law. Its resolutions, though, pushed schools in Europe and the United States toward speech-only teaching for decades. Many Deaf teachers lost their jobs, and signing was discouraged or banned in many classrooms. In 2010, the International Congress on Education of the Deaf formally rejected the resolutions.
What the Milan congress was
The Second International Congress on Education of the Deaf met in Milan, Italy, from September 6 to 11, 1880. Its organizing committee was made up of hearing educators. Most of the roughly 164 invited delegates were hearing teachers from Italy and France, and many of them favored oral methods. Delegates from several other countries also attended, including the United States and Britain.
Some Deaf teachers came without an invitation and were admitted, but they did not have an equal vote. The figure most often cited is one Deaf delegate.
The resolutions and the vote
The congress passed a set of resolutions favoring the “pure oral method,” meaning speech alone. One declared the “incontestable superiority of speech over signs.” Most accounts describe the vote as overwhelmingly in favor, reported as about 160 to 4.
Several delegates opposed the resolutions. The American dissenters included Edward Miner Gallaudet, who led what is now Gallaudet University, and the British delegate Richard Elliott.
Why non-binding resolutions still shaped schools
The Milan resolutions were not laws. They had no binding force on their own. But schools and governments adopted them, and the idea of speech-only education spread. That is why the congress is still discussed as a turning point, even though it did not formally outlaw anything.
What happened to sign language and Deaf teachers
Signing was pushed out of many European classrooms. Deaf teachers lost jobs or were demoted, and sign language lost ground in schools that had used it. In the United States the shift took decades. The change was not overnight, and residential schools, Deaf clubs and religious gatherings kept ASL in use. Oral methods remained dominant in many schools well into the twentieth century.
How the Deaf community responded
The National Association of the Deaf was founded in Cincinnati in 1880, the same year as the congress. In 1913 its former president, George Veditz, was filmed signing The Preservation of the Sign Language so that signing would be recorded for later generations. Gallaudet College kept using sign language, which helped keep ASL alive in the United States.
The reversal: 1960 to 2010
In 1960, William Stokoe’s Sign Language Structure argued that ASL has the structure of a true language, a view that changed how many researchers and educators regarded it. In July 2010, the International Congress on Education of the Deaf, meeting in Vancouver, formally rejected the Milan resolutions and apologized for their effects.
Does Italy have a sign language?
Yes. Italy has its own sign language, Italian Sign Language, known as LIS (Lingua dei Segni Italiana). It is a separate language from spoken Italian, and it is not the same as ASL.
Is there an international sign language?
Not in the sense of one fixed language. International Sign is a contact system that Deaf people from different countries use at international events. It relies on gestures and a shared set of signs, and it has less fixed grammar than a national sign language, so meaning often depends on context.
Other turning points
- 1880: The Milan congress and the oral-method resolutions.
- 1913: The Preservation of the Sign Language is filmed by the NAD.
- 1960: Stokoe’s study shows that ASL is a language.
- March 1988: The Deaf President Now protest at Gallaudet University. See the Gallaudet University story.
- 1990: The Americans with Disabilities Act is signed.
Common misconceptions
- Milan was a legal ban. It produced non-binding resolutions, which schools and governments then adopted.
- Sign language disappeared after 1880. It survived in residential schools, Deaf clubs and community life.
- US schools went oral overnight. The shift took decades.
For the broader timeline, read the history of ASL and how it has changed.