Short answer
For some nonverbal and autistic learners, signs can work as a form of augmentative and alternative communication (AAC). This is often done through key word signing: a small set of signs used together with speech. Sign does not need prerequisites, and research reviews have not found that it slows speech development. Decisions about a learner’s communication are best made with a speech-language pathologist (SLP), ideally as part of a team.
AAC in brief
AAC means augmentative and alternative communication: any method that supplements or replaces speech. It falls into two groups:
- Unaided AAC uses only the body: manual signs, gestures, pointing and facial expression.
- Aided AAC uses tools, such as picture boards, Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS) cards, communication books, speech-generating devices and AAC apps.
Signs are often used as key words. The learner signs the most important words while speaking, in spoken-language word order.
Key word signing systems
Several systems are built for this purpose:
- Makaton (UK, developed in the 1970s) combines signs and symbols. Its vocabulary is based on BSL signs.
- Signalong (UK) is also based on BSL. Signs are used alongside spoken English, following English word order.
- Key Word Sign (Australia) follows the same general idea.
In the United States, ASL signs are commonly borrowed for key word signing. These systems borrow signs, but they do not use the full grammar of a natural sign language. For how this differs from ASL or BSL, see whether sign language is a type of AAC.
Who might use sign as AAC
Sign may be considered for learners who are nonverbal or have limited speech, including some autistic learners and learners with other additional needs. Suitability depends on the individual. The same method may suit one learner and not another.
- Sign requires fine motor control and imitation skills. Some learners find a picture system or a device easier.
- Autistic signers may show distinct patterns, such as reversing palm orientation. An SLP can help decide whether and how to work on these.
- Simplified handshapes are fine for learners who have motor difficulties.
Which signs to start with
Start with signs the learner will want often and can see clearly in daily life. Common first signs include:
- more
- eat
- drink
- help
- all done or finished
- want
- stop
- play
Choose signs that match the learner’s routines and motivations rather than working through a fixed list.
Teaching signs in everyday routines
- Model signs during real activities. Sign “eat” at snack time rather than in a drill.
- Use hand-over-hand prompting sparingly, and fade it as soon as the learner can manage without it.
- Accept approximations. A simplified form that people can understand is a good start.
- Keep it consistent. Caregivers, teachers and peers need to learn and use the same signs.
Does sign slow down speech?
A 2006 review by Millar, Light and Schlosser found that AAC, including sign, did not hinder speech development, and many studies reported speech gains. The American Speech-Language-Hearing Association’s position is that there are no cognitive or age prerequisites for starting AAC. Talk with an SLP about the learner’s own needs.
Strengths and limits
Sign has real advantages. It is always available, it needs no batteries, chargers or devices, and it is quick. It also works in water and outdoors.
It has limits too. Few people outside the learner’s close circle understand sign, whereas a speech-generating device can be understood by anyone who hears it. Sign also needs fine motor control and memory.
Combining sign with other tools
Many SLPs recommend a multimodal approach: sign, pictures, a device and speech used together. The learner can use whichever method works best in a given situation. Some AAC apps include sign videos or symbol libraries.
Getting professional support
If you think AAC could help, talk to the learner’s team. This may include a speech-language pathologist, a teacher of the deaf, an occupational therapist, an early intervention team or an educational team. Together they can help decide whether AAC is a good fit and which options to try. Some areas have lending libraries where you can try equipment before you buy it.
Common misconceptions
- “Signing will stop my child from talking.” Research reviews do not support this.
- “A child must be ready before starting AAC.” There are no prerequisites.
- “Key word signing is ASL or BSL.” It borrows signs but not the grammar.
- “Sign is the best AAC for every autistic child.” Suitability varies with motor skills, imitation and the learner’s preferences.
- “AAC is a last resort after speech therapy.” It can start early and can run alongside speech therapy.