Learning Sign Language

Is sign language a type of AAC?

Sign language isn't AAC, but signs used to support speech are. Learn the difference, what key word signing is, and why Deaf people often reject the label.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. AAC in brief
  3. Why ASL and BSL are not AAC
  4. When signing counts as AAC
  5. Key word signing systems
  6. Why the label matters to Deaf people
  7. Combining sign with other AAC
  8. Where to get help
  9. Common misconceptions

Short answer

It depends on how the signing is used. Natural sign languages such as ASL and BSL are full languages, not AAC. Signs used to support or replace speech for someone with a communication disability are AAC. The same sign can be either, depending on the setting and the person.

AAC in brief

AAC means augmentative and alternative communication. It covers any method that supplements or replaces speech or writing for someone with a communication difficulty. It falls into two groups:

  • Unaided AAC needs no equipment. It includes manual signs, gestures, pointing and facial expression.
  • Aided AAC uses tools, from picture boards and communication books to speech-generating devices and apps.

The American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (ASHA) classes manual signs as unaided AAC when they are used clinically to support speech.

Why ASL and BSL are not AAC

ASL, BSL and other sign languages are full natural languages. They have their own grammar, structure and word order, and they are not simply signed versions of English. Linguists have recognised them as languages since William Stokoe’s work in 1960.

When Deaf people use ASL or BSL as their first language, they are using a language, in the same way a hearing person uses English. That is why most linguists do not describe these languages as AAC.

When signing counts as AAC

Context decides the label. Consider two examples:

  • A hearing autistic child who signs “more” at snack time to ask for more food is using AAC.
  • A Deaf adult who signs ASL to talk with friends, at work or in a meeting is using a language.

The sign itself may look the same in both cases. What changes is how and why it is used.

Key word signing systems

Some systems are designed as AAC. They use signs for key words, usually in spoken-language word order, alongside speech:

  • Makaton (UK) combines signs and symbols. It is a language programme used to support communication, and its basic vocabulary is drawn from BSL signs.
  • Signalong (UK) is also based on BSL. Signs are used alongside spoken English.
  • Key Word Sign (Australia) follows a similar idea.

Makaton is not a sign language. It is a communication programme that uses signs and symbols. For a broader comparison of BSL and Makaton, see which sign language to learn.

Why the label matters to Deaf people

Many Deaf people and sign language linguists object to describing ASL or BSL as AAC or as a disability aid. They see these languages as complete languages with their own culture and history. Respectful language matters here. Describe the signing by its purpose, for example “signs used as AAC for a nonverbal child,” rather than calling the language itself a tool.

Combining sign with other AAC

Many AAC users combine sign with other tools, such as pictures, devices and speech. This is often called a multimodal approach. It gives a person more than one way to communicate, and they can use whichever method works best in each situation.

Where to get help

If you are considering AAC for a child or adult, speak with a speech-language pathologist (SLP). An SLP can assess the person’s communication needs and advise on which systems to try. For a more detailed look at sign as AAC, see sign language as AAC for nonverbal and autistic learners.

Common misconceptions

  • “All sign language is AAC.” Natural sign languages are languages, not assistive technology.
  • “Makaton is a sign language.” It is a language programme that uses signs and symbols.
  • “AAC must involve a device.” Unaided AAC uses no equipment at all.
  • “Using sign as AAC delays speech.” Research reviews do not support this.

The complete guide to learning sign language

Which Sign Language Should You Learn?
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →