Short answer
Neither BSL nor ASL is objectively easier. Both are full natural languages of similar complexity. Which one feels easier depends on where you live, the learning resources near you, and the people you can practise with.
The easiest language to learn is usually the one you can practise with Deaf signers nearby.
Why sign languages can’t be ranked
Spoken languages have difficulty ratings, such as those published by the US Foreign Service Institute. Sign languages have no official equivalent. Any ranking you see online reflects one person’s experience, not a measured standard.
Fingerspelling: one hand or two
- ASL uses a one-handed alphabet. This frees your other hand, but it is harder to read at speed.
- BSL uses a two-handed alphabet. The vowels sit on the fingertips of the non-dominant hand, which many learners find easy to remember.
Both take time to become fast. The BSL alphabet article explains how the two-handed alphabet works.
Vocabulary and mouthing
ASL uses more initialised signs, where the handshape is the first letter of the English word, and more fingerspelling. BSL uses more English mouthing, which can help English speakers follow along.
Both languages vary by region. BSL variation is notable for numbers, colours and days. ASL also varies, for example Black ASL.
Grammar: what both share
Both use topic-comment order, facial grammar, use of space and pointing, and depicting signs. Neither follows English grammar, so knowing English does not make either one easy.
The difficulties differ, though:
- ASL learners often struggle with classifiers, facial grammar and reading fingerspelling.
- BSL learners often struggle with regional variants, mouth patterns and the speed of two-handed spelling.
Resources for each
- BSL: BSL SignBank from UCL, SignBSL.com, the free introductory course on British-Sign.co.uk, and BSL Zone. The free BSL courses guide goes into more detail.
- ASL: Lifeprint (ASL University, run by Bill Vicars) and many US YouTube channels.
Qualification routes
- BSL: Signature awards, including Levels 1, 2, 3, 4 and 6. They need assessment at approved centres.
- ASL: college ASL courses, typically levels 1 to 4. In the US, interpreters are certified through the Registry of Interpreters for the Deaf (RID).
How to decide
Ask yourself three questions:
- Where do you live, and who can you practise with?
- Do you want to sign with Deaf people in the UK or in North America?
- Do you want a formal qualification, and which route is open to you?
If the answers point to one country, that is usually your language. For a broader view of learning BSL, read the BSL for beginners guide.
Conversational basics usually take months to reach in either language. Fluency takes years.
Common misconceptions
- “ASL is easier because it’s more popular.” Popularity brings resources, not simpler grammar.
- “ASL works with British Deaf people.” The two languages are unrelated.
- “Knowing English makes either one easy.” The grammar differs.
- “Fingerspelling is the hardest part.” Most learners find faces and grammar harder.
For the wider differences between the two, see the ASL vs BSL comparison.