Short answer
In September 1880, the Second International Congress on the Education of the Deaf in Milan voted that speech was superior to sign in deaf education. The vote was a conference resolution, not a law. Even so, schools across Europe and the United States adopted it, and sign language was pushed out of many classrooms for about a century.
What the Milan Congress was
The congress met in Milan from 6 to 11 September 1880. It was organised largely by oralists, who believed deaf children should learn to speak and lip-read. The meeting was presided over by Abbé Giulio Tarra. About 164 delegates attended, mostly from Italy and France. Only one or a few of them were deaf, though sources differ on the exact number.
The first resolution, that speech was superior to signs, passed by 160 votes to 4. A second resolution backed the “pure oral method” over approaches that combined speech with sign.
Why the organisers favoured speech
The reasons given at the time included:
- integrating deaf people into hearing society through speech
- a belief that signing got in the way of lip-reading and speech
- religious arguments, including the idea that confession should be spoken
- ideals of national-language unity
Historians also point to wider views of sign as “primitive”, and to eugenic thinking in some accounts. Treat these as the background to the decision rather than as the reasons the organisers stated.
Who was not in the room
Deaf people were almost entirely excluded. Some Deaf teachers were admitted to the congress, but they had no vote. The American delegates, including Edward Miner Gallaudet and Thomas Gallaudet, opposed the resolutions. So did Britain’s Richard Elliott.
Was sign language banned everywhere?
No. The Milan vote was not a law, and its effect was uneven. Some schools changed quickly and others more slowly. Many Deaf teachers lost their jobs as schools moved to oral teaching.
Alexander Graham Bell, a strong advocate of oral teaching, wrote an 1883 memoir on deafness that is sometimes cited in this debate. Accounts of his role at Milan vary, so it is best not to overstate it.
What happened in Britain
The Royal Commission on the Blind, Deaf and Dumb recommended oral teaching in 1889. Deaf people responded through their own organisations. The US National Association of the Deaf was formed in 1880, and the British Deaf and Dumb Association, now the British Deaf Association, was founded in 1890.
Signing did not disappear from British deaf life, though. It continued in clubs, families and among pupils who used it out of sight of teachers.
How sign language survived
Oralism dominated deaf education for about a century. Sign languages survived in dormitories, Deaf clubs and families. Deaf communities passed their languages on, even where schools discouraged signing.
From the 1970s, Total Communication approaches, which combine sign and speech, spread in many places. From the 1980s onward, bilingual education gained ground. It treats a sign language and a written or spoken language as separate languages.
The 2010 apology
At the 21st International Congress on the Education of the Deaf, held in Vancouver in 2010, delegates formally rejected the Milan resolutions and apologised for them. The Irish Deaf Society’s published charter on sign language rights also regrets the 1880 resolutions.
What this means for BSL and ISL today
Legal recognition is one way Deaf communities have responded to that history. The British Sign Language Act 2022 recognises BSL as a language of England, Wales and Scotland. Ireland’s Irish Sign Language Act 2017 recognises ISL as a native, independent language.
Common misconceptions
- “A law banned sign worldwide.” It was a conference resolution, applied unevenly.
- “Oralism began in 1880.” It came before Milan. Samuel Heinicke in Germany is one early example.
- “Deaf people agreed.” They were almost entirely excluded.
- “Bell organised Milan.” Accounts of his role vary, so do not overstate it.
For a wider introduction to BSL, read the British Sign Language for beginners guide.